Setlist[]
| Order | Song | Album |
| 1 | "Lizard Suit" | Dark in Here |
| 2 | "Lovecraft in Brooklyn" | Heretic Pride |
| 3 | "First Blood" | Bleed Out |
| 4 | "Water Tower" | Jenny from Thebes |
| 5 | "Dark In Here" | Dark in Here |
| 6 | "Stabbed to Death Outside San Juan" | Beat the Champ |
| 7 | "Fresh Tattoo" | Jenny from Thebes |
| 8 | "Grendel's Mother" | Zopilote Machine |
| 9 | "Going to Palestine" | Unreleased |
| 10 | "Source Decay" | All Hail West Texas |
| 11 | "If I Should Fall From Grace With God" (The Pogues) | Unreleased |
| 12 | "Clean Slate" | Jenny from Thebes |
| 13 | "Abandoned Flesh" | Goths |
| 14 | "Only One Way" | Jenny from Thebes |
| 15 | "Cry for Judas" | Transcendental Youth |
| 16 | "You or Your Memory" | The Sunset Tree |
| 17 | "See America Right" | Tallahassee |
| 18 | "No Children" | Tallahassee |
| 19 | "Up the Wolves" | The Sunset Tree |
| 20 | "This Year" | The Sunset Tree |
| 21 | "Heel Turn 2" | Beat the Champ |
Notes[]
- Songs 8-11 were performed by John Darnielle solo.
- The encore was songs 19 through 21.