Setlist[]
| Order | Song | Album |
| 1 | "High Hawk Season" | All Eternals Deck |
| 2 | "Moon Over Goldsboro" | Get Lonely |
| 3 | "New Star Song" | Beautiful Rat Sunset |
| 4 | "Southwood Plantation Road" | Tallahassee |
| 5 | "1 Samuel 15:23" | The Life of the World to Come |
| 6 | "Lovecraft in Brooklyn" | Heretic Pride |
| 7 | "No More Tears" | Marsh Witch Visions |
| 8 | "Going to Jamaica" | Taking the Dative/Ghana |
| 9 | "Wear Black" | Goths |
| 10 | "In Memory of Satan" | Transcendental Youth |
| 11 | "San Bernardino" | Heretic Pride |
| 12 | "Foreign Object" | Beat the Champ |
| 13 | "Stabbed to Death Outside San Juan" | Beat the Champ |
| 14 | "Damn These Vampires" | All Eternals Deck |
| 15 | "Hast Thou Considered the Tetrapod" | The Sunset Tree |
| 16 | "The Diaz Brothers" | Transcendental Youth |
| 17 | "Up the Wolves" (video) | The Sunset Tree |
| 18 | "This Year" | The Sunset Tree |
| 19 | "Love and Marriage" (Frank Sinatra; partial) | Unreleased |
| 20 | "No Children" | Tallahassee |
Notes[]
- Songs 7 through 9 were performed by John Darnielle and Matt Douglas.
- The encore was songs 16 through 20.