Setlist[]
| Order | Song | Album |
| 1 | "In Memory of Satan" | Transcendental Youth |
| 2 | "Thank You Mario But Our Princess Is in Another Castle" | Black Pear Tree EP |
| 3 | "Pale Green Things" | The Sunset Tree |
| 4 | "Love Love Love" | The Sunset Tree |
| 5 | "You Were Cool" | Unreleased |
| 6 | "Game Shows Touch Our Lives" | Tallahassee |
| 7 | "This Year" (with John and Hank Green and a whole bunch of other people) | The Sunset Tree |
Notes[]
- This John Darnielle and Jon Wurster duo show was part of John & Hank Green's "An Evening of Awesome".
- Video of the Mountain Goats's entire set is viewable here.
- "This Year" was performed at a different time than the rest of the set, at the end of the entire show, and all of the performers joined the Goats for the finale. (video)