Setlist[]
| Order | Song | Album |
| 1 | "1 Samuel 15:23" | The Life of the World to Come |
| 2 | "Psalms 40:2" | The Life of the World to Come |
| 3 | "Isaiah 45:23" (video) | The Life of the World to Come |
| 4 | "Love Love Love" (video) | The Sunset Tree |
| 5 | "Cotton" (video) | We Shall All Be Healed |
Notes[]
- The Mountain Goats were featured in season one of Dinner with the Band, a show where the host chef prepares a meal for a band. "1 Samuel 15:23" and "Psalms 40:2" were included in the full episode, while the other three songs were released as "webisodes" before the episode aired.
- Judging from Peter Hughes' Tumblr, the episode was recorded in February 2010.