Setlist[]
| Order | Song | Album |
| 1 | "This Year"* (Unaired) | The Sunset Tree |
| 2 | "Psalms 40:2"(video) | The Life of the World to Come |
Songs with a (*) are played with Stephen Colbert.
Notes[]
- This is the band's first televised appearance.
- Stephen Colbert professed himself a fan.
- During the commercial break, Stephen and the band played "This Year". It was unaired.